I Keep Baking These 9 Cookies Because Everyone Loves Them

Some weeks just call for some baking, and these cookies never fail to impress. Out of all the cookie recipes I’ve made, these are the ones my friends and family love the most.

Each recipe brings its own little twist, from fudgy centers to nostalgic flavors. If you’re looking for treats that disappear quickly from the plate, this list has you covered.

1. Brownie Cookies

Top view of brownie cookies on a wooden table. — Photo Credit: NeighborFood

These cookies blend the chewy richness of a brownie with a soft, fudgy center. Their crackly tops and fudgy centers make them a crowd pleaser.

Get the Recipe: Brownie Cookies

2. Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches

Peanut butter cookie sandwiches on a white plate. — Photo Credit: Melissa’s Southern Style Kitchen

Two soft peanut butter cookies hold a smooth chocolate ganache filling, adding a touch of indulgence. They’re a fun option when you want something a little more memorable than a standard cookie.

Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches

3. Banana Cream Pudding Cookies

Top view of banana cream pudding cookies. — Photo Credit: The Baking Chocolatess

These cookies use pudding mix to create banana flavor throughout. They come together quickly, making them a good pick when you want a warm batch without much effort.

Get the Recipe: Banana Cream Pudding Cookies

4. White Chocolate Macadamia Coconut Cookies

Stack of white chocolate macadamia coconut cookies on a wooden board. — Photo Credit: Melissa’s Southern Style Kitchen

White chocolate, macadamias, and coconut combine for a cookie that balances sweetness with a bit of crunch. The edges bake up crisp while the center stays pleasantly chewy.

Get the Recipe: White Chocolate Macadamia Coconut Cookies

5. Birthday Cake Cookies

Birthday cake cookies topped with colorful sprinkles. — Photo Credit: Baking Beauty

These thick cookies are finished with a swirl of cake batter buttercream that is so delicious. They’re great for anyone who likes the flavor of classic birthday cake without needing to bake an actual cake.

Get the Recipe: Birthday Cake Cookies

6. Twix Cookies

Twix cookies on parchment paper topped with caramel and chocolate. — Photo Credit: The Soccer Mom Blog

A buttery base is topped with caramel and chocolate to create a cookie reminiscent of the Twix. You might even like these better than the candy bar!

Get the Recipe: Twix Cookies

7. Raspberry White Chocolate Cookies

Raspberry white chocolate cookies on a cooling rack. — Photo Credit: The Baking Chocolatess

Raspberries and sweet white chocolate give these cookies a flavor combo that stands out from the usual choices. Each bite balances bright fruit notes with creamy chocolate pieces.

Get the Recipe: Raspberry White Chocolate Cookies

8. Kitchen Sink Cookies

Top view of kitchen sink cookies on a plate. — Photo Credit: Noshing with the Nolands

These cookies make good use of whatever mix-ins you have around, from nuts to different baking chips. The varied textures keep each batch interesting and different from the last.

Get the Recipe: Kitchen Sink Cookies

9. Nutella Stuffed Cookies

Nutella-stuffed cookies broken open to show the melted chocolate filling. — Photo Credit: Lifestyle of a Foodie

A soft cookie exterior hides a warm Nutella center that melts as the cookies cool. They’re especially appealing for anyone who enjoys a gooey middle in their baked treats.

Get the Recipe: Nutella Stuffed Cookies