11 Cookies That Are Always Crowd Pleasers

Some cookies seem to disappear the moment you set them out. The recipes on this list are always crowd pleasers and never fail to impress.

You’ll find a mix of classics and fun twists that always get excellent reviews from everyone. No matter which one you choose, these cookies are the kind that never stay on the plate for long.

1. Soft M&M Sugar Cookies

Set out a plate of these delicious M&M cookies at a potluck or party and watch them get devoured. You can even change the M&M flavors or use seasonal ones, depending on the occasion.

Get the Recipe: Soft M&M Sugar Cookies

2. Peanut Butter Cookies

These cookies bring together a familiar mix of sweet peanut flavor with a light salty finish for a crowd-pleasing treat. Their crisp edges and soft centers give them that classic homemade feel that everyone loves.

Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Cookies

3. Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies

Chunks of real strawberry pair with a smooth cream cheese filling for a cookie that’ll have everyone wanting the recipe. If you’re craving cheesecake and cookies, no need to decide between the two; make these.

Get the Recipe: Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies

4. Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies

Each cookie hides an Oreo inside, giving every bite a mix of soft dough and a crunchy cookie center. It’s a fun twist on traditional chocolate chip cookies and feels extra indulgent.

Get the Recipe: Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies

5. Crumbl Sugar Cookies

This Crumbl copycat has a soft cookie base topped with creamy buttercream. They capture the familiar Crumbl flavor but are much more cost-effective to whip up at home.

Get the Recipe: Crumbl Sugar Cookies

6. Kitchen Sink Cookies

These cookies blend sweet add-ins with salty bites like pretzels for a mix that keeps things interesting. The caramel and toffee bits paired with the pretzels are so yummy!

Get the Recipe: Kitchen Sink Cookies

7. Black and White Cookies

These soft cookies are coated with both vanilla and chocolate icing for the signature two-tone look. Wherever you bring them, one thing is for sure: people go wild for these cookies.

Get the Recipe: Black and White Cookies

8. Dark Chocolate Chip Cookies

Dark chocolate lovers will really enjoy this decadent cookie. They’re rich without being overly sweet, making them a favorite.

Get the Recipe: Dark Chocolate Chip Cookies

9. White Chocolate Raspberry Cookies

White chocolate and raspberries are always a winning combo, and these cookies prove it! Plus, they couldn’t be easier to make.

Get the Recipe: White Chocolate Raspberry Cookies

10. Jacques Torres Cookies

This copycat chocolate chip cookie from a famous New York bakery is a must-try recipe. It’s a great pick when you want a homemade cookie that feels like it came from a bakery.

Get the Recipe: Jacques Torres Cookies

11. Cosmic Brownie Cookies

These cookies give you all the fudgy richness of a brownie and are finished off with homemade chocolate ganache and fun rainbow candy chocolate bits. This one is wildly popular with kids and adults.

Get the Recipe: Cosmic Brownie Cookies