10 Thanksgiving Desserts For A Crowd

Thanksgiving desserts are one of those things that everyone looks forward to just as much as the turkey. Between the cozy flavors, warm spices, and mix of classic and creative treats, it’s hard to choose just one favorite.

Whether you’re hosting dinner or simply bringing something sweet to share, it’s nice to have options that look impressive without adding extra stress. Each one brings a little something special to the table.

1. Pumpkin Trifle

Pumpkin trifle dessert — Photo Credit: Princess Pinky Girl

This showstopper looks fancy but comes together with boxed cake mix and store-bought whipped topping. It needs to chill overnight, which makes it perfect for making ahead.

Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Trifle

2. Apple Crisp Mini Cheesecakes

Bite-sized apple crisp cheesecakes with crumble topping on a plate. — Photo Credit: Savvy Honey

My recipe for apple crisp mini cheesecakes is a must-try. Every bite gives you creamy cheesecake plus the warm spices of an apple crisp. The brown sugar oat crumble on top is so yummy!

Get the Recipe: Apple Crisp Mini Cheesecakes

3. Pecan Pie Bars

Stacked pecan pie bars with gooey nut filling and flaky crust. — Photo Credit: I Heart Naptime

Everyone loves pecan pie, but cutting clean slices can be a mess. These bars give you that same gooey, nutty filling on a shortbread base that cuts perfectly every time, making them way easier to serve to a crowd.

Get the Recipe: Pecan Pie Bars

4. Turkey Cupcakes

Close-up of turkey cupcakes with frosting and candy corn feathers. — Photo Credit: Sugar and Soul

These turkey cupcakes are adorable and will be a hit with both kids and adults. They’re so easy to decorate.

Get the Recipe: Turkey Cupcakes

5. Mini Sweet Potato Pies

Mini sweet potato pies on a plate. — Photo Credit: Persnickety Plates

Using phyllo cups means you skip making pie crust entirely, and they bake up golden in a little over 30 minutes. The homemade cinnamon cream cheese frosting on top feels a little unexpected in the best way, like a sweet potato casserole met a cupcake.

Get the Recipe: Mini Sweet Potato Pies

6. Pumpkin Marble Cake

Pumpkin marble bundt cake with chocolate swirls, dusted with powdered sugar. — Photo Credit: I Heart Eating

The chocolate swirl pumpkin cake will be a new family favorite. Bundt cakes are forgiving and don’t need frosting, so you can just dust it with powdered sugar and call it done.

Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Marble Cake

7. Turkey Leg Rice Krispies Treats

Close-up of turkey leg Rice Krispies with pretzel ends. — Photo Credit: Persnickety Plates

These turkey leg Rice Krispies treats might be the cutest Thanksgiving dessert ever. The chocolate “gravy” is such a clever touch.

Get the Recipe: Turkey Leg Rice Krispies Treats

8. Chocolate Cream Pie

Close-up of chocolate cream pie slice served on a plate. — Photo Credit: Valerie’s Kitchen

From the crust to the whipped cream and chocolate custard, everything in this recipe is homemade. It might take a little longer to make than recipes not made from scratch, but trust us, it’s worth the extra effort.

Get the Recipe: Chocolate Cream Pie

9. Apple Pie

Top view of apple pie with golden lattice crust. — Photo Credit: Cheerful Cook

Some people show up just for the apple pie, and this one never disappoints. The lattice crust will impress everyone and is suprisingly easier than it looks.

Get the Recipe: Apple Pie

10. Pumpkin Crunch Cake

Pumpkin layer cake with frosting and pumpkin decorations, with a slice cut out. — Photo Credit: SugarYums

This is the cake that makes people stop mid-conversation just to compliment. The real shredded pumpkin keeps it incredibly moist, and those caramelized walnuts between the layers are so delicious.

Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Crunch Cake